Fight
Hollywood's Bigots for the Left, contribute to
Media Action Network for Asian Americans (www.manaa.org)
and the Center For Asian American Media (www.asianamericanmedia.org)
“The Last
Airbender”
Producers: Scott Aversano, Frank Marshall, Sam Mercer, M. Night Shyamalan
Executive producers: Michael Dante DiMartino, Kathleen Kennedy, Bryan Konietzko
Co-producer: Jose L. Rodriguez
Director: M. Night Shyamalan
Casting: Douglas Aibel
Paramount Pictures
In his December 23, 2009 “Answer Man” update, film critic Roger Ebert
publicly condemned the casting of The Last Airbender film.
Arlene C. Harris
Q: Regarding the upcoming M. Night Shyamalan vehicle The Last Airbender, what do
you think about the whitewashing of the production...?
A.
Wrong. The original series Avatar: The Last Airbender was highly regarded and
popular for three seasons on Nickelodeon. Its fans take it for granted that its
heroes are Asian. Why would Paramount and Shyamalan go out of their way to
offend these fans? There are many young Asian actors capable of playing the
parts.
"The Goods: Live Hard, Sell Hard,"
- Gary Sanchez Productions
- Producers: Will Ferrell, Chris Henchy, Adam McKay, Kevin J. Messick,
- Executive Producer: Louise Rosner
- Director: Neal Brennan
- Screenplay: Andy Stock, Rick Stempson
8/18/09 AFP: “Japanese
American group outraged by film,”
Los Angeles
— A Japanese-American group on Monday demanded an apology over a film
starring Jeremy Piven due to a scene satirically depicting the mob beating of an
Asian American man.
"The Goods: Live Hard, Sell Hard," which opened in
sixth place in the North American box office last Friday, is a comedy about a
down-and-out used-car salesman played by Piven who tries to make it big with a
Fourth of July sale.
On the trailer seen on the movie's official website, Piven's
character is seen shouting at an Asian American employee at the dealership:
"Don't get me started on
Pearl Harbor
. We are Americans and they are the enemy! Never again!"
As the Asian American -- played by Korean American actor Ken
Jeong -- sheepishly joins in chanting "Never again!," an older white
man says, "Let's get him!" and the employees beat him up.
The Japanese American Citizens League said Piven's character
also used the racial slur "Jap" in the movie and, acknowledging it was
a hate crime, asked employees to say the Asian American was attacking them with
a samurai sword.
Saying the film showed a "shocking lack of
judgment," the group said the producers "need to apologize because
they crossed a line in thinking they could use a racial slur simply for the sake
of a laugh."
"Japanese Americans are particularly offended because we
painfully recall how slurs were used during the 1940s to vilify and demean our
community, resulting in a forced eviction from our homes," it said.
Authorities herded more than 100,000 Japanese Americans, most
of them
US
citizens, into internment camps months after
Japan
attacked Pearl Harbor in 1941, dragging the
United States
into World War II.
Paramount Pictures, owned by conglomerate Viacom, said the
film -- distributed in the
United States
by its division Paramount Vantage -- "satirizes and exaggerates the
extremes of the sales and celebrity culture."
"We understand that when presented out of context, jokes
and situations in the movie about a variety of topics might be offensive to some
people," it said in a statement.
"To be very clear, 'The Goods: Live Hard, Sell Hard' is
in no way meant to be mean-spirited, disparaging or hurtful to any individuals
and we regret any offense taken," it said.
It is the first movie for Piven since he appeared in the hit
HBO television series "Entourage."
"Kung Fu"
Conceived by Bruce Lee, but they cast a Caucasian
in the lead role.
Producers: Jerry Thorpe, Alex Beaton
Director: Jerry Thorpe
Casting: Lynn Stalmaster
"Romeo Must Die"
Based on Romeo and Juliet, but they changed the ending so that the Asian Romeo
(Jet Li) does not kiss Juliet (Aaliyah
Haughton)
Bigots for the Left:
Warner Brothers Pictures:
- Barry M. Meyer,
Chairman & Chief Executive Officer,
- Alan F. Horn, President & Chief Operating Officer
- Ed Romano, Executive Vice
President and Chief Financial Officer
Silver Pictures: Joel Silver
- Executive Producer: Dan Cracchiolo
- Producer: Joel Silver
- Producer: Jim Van Wyck
- Co-producer: Warren Carr
- Associate producer: Mitchell Kapner
- Associate producer: Ilyse A. Reutlinger
"21"
Even though most of the actual blackjack team was composed of Asian
American male MIT students, a studio executive involved in the casting process
said that most of the film's actors would be white, with perhaps an Asian
female. In real life, most of the blackjack team was
Asian Americans.
Bigots for the Left:
- Executive producers: William S. Beasley, Ryan
Kavanaugh, Brett Ratner
- Producers: Dana Brunetti, Michael De Luca, Kevin Spacey
- Casting: Francine Maisler
3/2508 www.angryasianman.com:
racist casting and 21,
There's been a lot of chatter and gripes lately about the
movie 21, which opens in theaters nationwide this Friday. Longtime readers know
that this movie has been on our radar for several years, ever since it was
announced that Sony had the film in development, with Kevin Spacey attached to
the project. Based on the bestselling book Bringing Down the House by Ben
Mezrich, it tells the story of how a team of gifted blackjack players from MIT
developed a highly successful card-counting system and took Las Vegas casinos
for millions. Based on a true story, it's a great premise, and the perfect idea
for a big budget
Hollywood
movie. Right? Not exactly.
You see, in real life, the blackjack team was a group mostly
made up of Asian American students. This was actually advantageous to their
strategy, as it happens, because Asian dudes winning big money at the casinos
apparently aren't quite as conspicuous as white dudes who win big at the
casinos. That's just the way it is. Anyway. As we all know,
Hollywood
studios seem to have a great of resistance to creating interesting,
fully-fleshed, three-dimensional roles for Asian American actors. They seem to
think we can't carry a movie, and more often than not, will instead create roles
and stories for pretty white people instead. I know this, you know this, we all
know this. Hell, they know this.
Case in point, 21. Except here, we actually have a true story
that involved real living, breathing Asian Americans, who have been magically
switched out on celluloid into-you guessed it-pretty white people. Namely, Kate
Bosworth and Jim Sturgess. This has pretty much been the plan since the
beginning, and now, the movie finally hits movie screens this week. Business as
usual. That's racist!
AICN has an interview
with Jeff Ma (www.aintitcool.com/node/36103)
the guy who Sturgess' character is based on. He doesn't seem to mind that
they've changed his character's ethnicity... I guess he's entitled to that.
It still doesn't change the fact that this movie was born out of the
stereotypical
Hollywood
casting process. This is from an
article on author Ben Mezrich and Bringin Down the House from 2005:http://www-tech.mit.edu/V125/N43/43vegas.html
This view is brought about in part by
Hollywood
, with films like "Ocean's Eleven,"in which gambling is made to seem
exotic and sexy. Incidentally, Mezrich's "Bringing Down the House" is
now being turned into a feature film by Kevin Spacey, who will play the MIT
professor who trained the blackjack team described in that book. During the
talk, Mezrich mentioned the stereotypical
Hollywood
casting process--though most of the actual blackjack team was composed of Asian
males, a studio executive involved in the casting process said that most of the
film's actors would be white, with perhaps an Asian female. Even as Asian actors
are entering more mainstream films, such as "Better Luck Tomorrow" and
the upcoming "Memoirs of a Geisha," these stereotypes still exist,
Mezrich said.
I must note that the movie's cast includes a couple of Asian
American characters, played by Aaron Yoo and Liza Lapira.
They're part of the blackjack team, and do have a (less prominent) place
on the movie poster. It counts for something. I really am glad that these two
are in the movie, apparently added later to mitigate some of the initial
controversy stirred up by this casting nonsense. Sure, it feels like the
producers are throwing us a bone. They are. What they're crafting is pure
Hollywood
falsity. But I'm happy to see that these two rising stars will get due exposure
in a high-profile movie a lot of people are going to see.
I'm okay with that. (I might have to take these statements back if/when I
actually see them in the movie.)
Now, there's a pretty vocal anti-21 movement that's been
growing over the last few months. This movie has got a lot of people angry.
There have even been calls for a an all-out boycott of 21. http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=24381965401
I'm going to put it out there-I'm not necessarily in favor of a
boycott, nor am I against one either. I'm not sure where I stand on that. But
I'm certainly in favor of anything that draws attention and educates people on
the issues at hand. This is a good one, because it brings scrutiny to the nature
of
Hollywood
's racist casting processes, with a very obvious, high-profile example. People
are interested in this movie, without a lot of background knowledge, but this is
an opportunity to create dialogue on a general practice that has systematically
shut out Asians in
Hollywood
for years. I hope it prompts folks understand what's going on here, learn the
details for themselves, talk about it, and perhaps approach 21 (and future
Hollywood
product) with a more discerning eye.
"Extraordinary Measures"
1/20/10 Roger Ebert: "Dr. Robert Stonehill doesn't exist in real life. The Pompe cure was developed by Dr. Yuan-Tsong Chen and his colleagues while he was at Duke University. He is now director of the Institute of Biomedical Science in Taiwan. Harrison Ford, as this film's executive producer, perhaps saw Stonehill as a plum role for himself; a rewrite was necessary because he couldn't very well play Dr. Chen. The real Chen, a Taiwan University graduate, worked his way up at Duke from a residency to professor and chief of medical genetics at the Duke University Medical Center. He has been mentioned as a Nobel candidate."
Bigots for the Left:
- Executive producers:
Harrison Ford, Nan Morales
- Producers: Carla Santos Shamberg,
Michael Shamberg, Stacey Sher
- Director: Tom Vaughn
- Casting: Margery Simkin, Lana Veenker
5/2/10 Los Angeles Times: "On the set: Casting
of ‘Last Airbender’ stirs controversy:
Although the source material is rooted in Far Eastern myth, M. Night
Shyamalan’s film cross-casts non-Asians,"
by Sam Adams
Philadelphia - By now, the movie industry has plenty of
practice weathering the complaints of fans who object to the inevitable
departures that accompany the adaptation of a pre-existing property to a
big-screen franchise. But the concerns that surfaced as M. Night Shyamalan went
into production on "The Last Airbender" were more serious than the
usual nitpicking. Amid the kvetching about the shape and size of the facial scar
sported by the film's chief villain were accusations that Shyamalan had
whitewashed the story, which was influenced by Asian art and mythology, by
casting Caucasian actors in many leading roles.
Noah Ringer, a tween tae kwon do champion from Texas, was
chosen for the role of Aang, a high-spirited boy who discovers that he is the
last surviving member of the Air Nation; "Twlight's" Jackson Rathbone
and Nicola Peltz ("Deck the Halls") were cast as his best friends,
Water Nation siblings Sokka and Katara.
The "Airbender" outcry was not unusual — the
controversy over Broadway's "Miss Saigon" is but one of many
forerunners. The source material for the Paramount Pictures film (which opens
July 2, and if all goes well will have two succeeding installments) is "
Avatar: The Last Airbender," an animated series that aired on Nickelodeon
from 2005 to 2008. (The first word was dropped from the big-screen project for
obvious reasons.)
Although creators Michael Dante DiMartino and Bryan Konietzko
were heavily influenced by Asian martial arts lore and incorporated elements of
Chinese and Tibetan cultures, the characters had no explicit race. But some
Asian Americans saw the film's casting as the latest in a string of insults from
an industry in which it was once common for white actors to squint their eyes
and spout fortune-cookie wisdom while Asian actors were confined to playing
opium-den extras.
On the film's Philadelphia set last summer, Shyamalan took
issue with the idea that "The Last Airbender" presents a lily-white
version of the cartoon's universe. "Ultimately, this movie, and then the
three movies, will be the most culturally diverse tentpole movies ever released,
period," he said. "So if I'm failing the bar, I'm not sure whose bar
is set higher than this movie." At the time when the criticisms first
surfaced early last year, boy-band heartthrob Jesse McCartney was set to play
the villainous Prince Zuko. But when he dropped out over conflicts with his
touring schedule, the role was recast with " Slumdog Millionaire's"
Dev Patel and the Fire Nation took on a darker hue. Iranian-born Shaun Toub was
cast as Patel's uncle and Maori actor Cliff Curtis as his father.
Toub, whose lengthy resume includes " Iron Man" and
" Crash," said that race-based casting would have come with its own
problems. "If they would have put all Asians in a certain nation, I think
then there would be people who come out and said, ‘Well, now you're
stereotyping, saying that anything that has to do with martial arts has to do
with Asians and chop suey and all that.' So it's nice to mix it up and just do
the unexpected."
Doing the unexpected extends to tapping perhaps the most
recognizable writer-director since Quentin Tarantino to film his first
adaptation as well as the first movie to step away from his patented (and, some
critics would say, tapped-out) thrillers.
"The long-form story was always really interesting to
me, but the idea of going away for three years to write a long-form movie didn't
seem realistic, at least right now," Shyamalan said. "One thing that's
very interesting is that, because it hasn't been mine from the inception, I've
had a little bit more perspective, so it isn't as painful to adapt or change
something. Just a hair more acceptance of the ability to do that is real
healthy, and now I can bring that to the movies I write as well."
Together with "Lord of the Rings" cinematographer
Andrew Lesnie, Shyamalan worked to strike a balance between the extensive CGI
demanded by the otherworldly setting of the story and a tactile reality conveyed
through long takes and real fight scenes. (Patel, like Ringer, has been
practicing martial arts since childhood.) His goal was to transfer the aesthetic
and work ethics of his earlier films onto the much larger stage of a summer
blockbuster, a task endorsed by producer Frank Marshall, who last worked with
Shyamalan on 2002's "Signs."
"I think what he's learned is how to take the ideas he
has, which were small before, and realize them in a movie like this without
losing the spirituality of the other movies," Marshall said. "He's
been able to keep that tone and that feeling and not be overwhelmed by the
process. There's still a lot of humanity in what we're doing and a lot of warmth
and depth to the characters. It's not overwhelmed by the fact that there's a lot
of special effects."
2/4/10
www.minnesota.publicradio.org:
"A look at "Yellow Face" in American entertainment,"
by Marianne Combs
Do you remember the show "Kung Fu" starring David
Carradine? You know the one where he has to walk on rice paper and pass all
sorts of tests to be a true shaolin monk? And then he goes on a quest in the
West to find his half-brother?
Did you know Bruce Lee was passed over for the part?
I didn't. Of course it doesn't really surprise me. "Sign
of the times... that was the early 70s... wouldn't happen today." Or at
least, so I thought, until I read David Henry Hwang's play "Yellow
Face."
The play, which opens this weekend at the Guthrie theater (in
a production staged by Theater Mu) is based in part on true tales from Hwang's
own career. And it reveals just how much race continues to play a very
frustrating role in casting in American media... especially for Asian-Americans.
A quick survey of American media reveals the truth to this.
Both Asian-American males and females tend to be relegated to the role of
"side-kick." Typically they are cast as the computer expert, or the
doctor. They are quiet, good-looking, and have excellent skills in the martial
arts.
So what's wrong with that, you ask? Heck, I'd love to be
good-looking, have a high paying job and a black belt to boot!
The problem is that our portrayal of Asian-Americans is
extremely narrow. There is no "average Asian-American family" on TV.
What Bill Cosby did for African-Americans (which, regardless of what you think
of the show, was to put their lives center stage) has yet to be accomplished for
Asian-Americans.
Margaret Cho gave it a shot with her 1994 TV program
"All American Girl." Complaints from network executives that her face
was "too round" led her to practically starve herself in the weeks
leading up to production (resulting in kidney failure), and at various stages
she was told she was being either "too asian" or "not asian
enough." The show lasted barely a year.
Today we're faced with a new version of type-casting.
Japanese-Americans and Korean-Americans are being roped in to play the roles of
"exotic" Japanese or Korean characters, as network television attempts
to appear more worldly.
Daniel Dae Kim was raised in both South Korea and
Pennsylvania, and trained in acting at New York University, but his character on
"Lost" spent most of the first two seasons speaking only Korean.
Actor Masi Oka has lived in Los Angeles since he was six, but
you'll only hear him speaking Japanese or English with a strong Japanese accent
on the show "Heroes"(except for a couple of rare exceptions involving
"alternate realities").
So while Warner Bros executives justified passing over Bruce
Lee for the lead in "Kung Fu" because his accent was too thick, we now
demand fluent english speakers to mix up their "L"s with their "R"s.
What gives?
This Saturday at 4pm, in conjunction with the opening of
"Yellow Face," I'll be moderating a panel discussion on just this
topic at the Guthrie Theater. On the panel will be playwright David Henry Hwang,
actor Randy Reyes, journalist Tom Lee, Josephine Lee from the Asian American
Studies Department at the University of Minnesota, and Star Tribune theater
critic Graydon Royce.
I'm sure it's going to be a fascinating conversation.
7/29/09 Los Angeles Examiner.com: "Does
Hollywood
'white-wash' the casting of Asian characters in movies?"
by Ed Moy
In my last column, I asked readers "Should Asian actors
have been cast as the leads in 'The Last Airbender'?
The responses overwhelmingly pointed toward a "Yes"
answer from most of the comments that I read.
Also, the topic of
Hollywood
"white-washing" ethnic characters in movies came up, especially
animated Asian characters.
After doing some online research, I discovered that "The
Last Airbender" wasn't the only recent movie that cast white actors in
roles that were originally created as Asian characters.
For example, the character of Kyo Kusanagi will be played by
Sean Farris in an upcoming live-action feature based on the video game
"King of Fighters".
There's also the casting of Jake Gyllenhaal as Prince Dastan
in "Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time" along with a British actress
Gemma Arterton playing his love-interest Tamina.
The movie was also based on a popular video game.
And then there's the recent announcement that Leonardo
DiCaprio and Joseph Gordon-Levitt are starring in a live-action version of the
Japanese anime "Akira."
And finally, there's the casting of Keanu Reeves as Spike
Spiegel in the live-action adaptation of "Cowboy Bebop."
(Although, I do admit that I think Keanu Reeves looks similar to the
character.)
This all of course pales in comparison to the fact that last
year, the producers of the movie "21" took poetic license in rewriting
actual Asian American card playing MIT students as white characters.
The movie "21" was based on the best-selling book
"Bringing Down the House", about a real-life team of mostly Asian
American students led by an Asian American professor John Chang and his teaching
cohorts.
The two main characters in the book, named "Kevin
Lewis" and "Steve Fisher", were based on Jeff Ma and Mike Aponte,
two Asian American males.
But somehow in the movie, Jeff Ma morphs into Jim Sturgess
and John Chang turns into Kevin Spacey.
Not only that but the only Asian American characters in the
movie are merely supporting roles played by Aaron Yoo and Liza Lapira.
Several organizations such as Media Action Network for Asian
Americans (MANAA) protested the movie and "Boycott 21" and other
anti-"21" websites sprang up on the Internet.
According to MANAA, after the “white-washing” issue was
raised on Entertainment Weekly's website, movie producer Dana Brunetti wrote:
“Believe me, I would have loved to cast Asians in the lead roles, but the
truth is, we didn't have access to any bankable Asian American actors that we
wanted… If I had known how upset the Asian American community would be about
this, I would have picked a different story to film.”
What? No bankable
Asian American actors? Who was
Brunetti kidding?
What about John Cho from the "American Pie" and
"Harold and Kumar" movies?
Or Leonardo Nam from "The Sisterhood of Traveling
Pants" movies?
Heck, they already had Aaron Yoo, who appeared in movies like
"Disturbia" and "The Wackness" before signing on for the
"21" debacle?
There were also a number of other recognizable Asian American
actors such as Roger Fan, Sung Kang, Ken Leung, Justin Chon, and the Yune
brothers, Rick and Karl available.
All of these aforementioned Asian American actors were no
less recognizable or bankable than Jim Sturgess, who was relatively unknown to
most American moviegoers before "21" came out.
It seems to me the studio and producers were looking to find
a new "hot" actor to sell with the movie release -- and Jim Sturgess
was their guy.
Ironically, Jeff Ma, who is Chinese American reportedly riled
up a lot of Asian Americans when he told USA Today, “I would have been a lot
more insulted if they had chosen someone who was Japanese or Korean, just to
have an Asian playing me.”
Really Jeff, you think that Jim Sturgess comes across way
more "cool" on screen playing you than John Cho could've done?
(Personally, if I was you, Jeff, I think I would've rather had the
ubiquitous Keanu Reeves play me. I
think most of Keanu's movies made more money than "21" didn't they?
Well, you're the MIT grad Jeff, I'll let you do the math on that one!)
But all
kidding aside, "21" was just one example from last year.
I'm sure there were other movies where this type of casting controversy
has happened in the past that I didn't even have time to look up yet.
In addition to the controversy surrounding "The Last
Airbender," this year, there was also an Asian American outcry over casting
for the recent live-action movie "Dragonball Evolution" based on the
Japanese anime and manga.
In the movie, Goku, the main character is played by a white
actor which caused some debate over why a Japanese anime character looks so
Westernized in the movie.
Also, not surprisingly, Goku was the lead male character and
the role went to a young Canadian actor rather than an Asian / Asian American
actor or even the forever ethnically-ambiguous Keanu Reeves, who usually ends up
with these kinds of roles. (By the way, if you're reading this Keanu, I love
your movies! I don't know why
critics are so harsh when it comes to your acting skills!
Seriously, I'm not being sarcastic here.
You can play me in any movie, bro! Of
course, Hollywood would have to wake up and decide to make an actual Asian
American movie where the lead roles aren't animated characters.
And yes, folks, I'm referring to the animated movie "Up" from
Disney Pixar, which features an Asian American wilderness scout named Russell,
who was based on the Korean American animator Peter Sohen.
Well, at least there's one Asian American leading male actor co-starring
in a major summer blockbuster movie this year, even if he is only an animated
little boy voiced by an Asian
American child actor.)
So with that all said folks, does Hollywood
"white-wash" the casting of Asian characters in movies?
I'll let you all decide that one.
FYI: There is an
Asian actor starring in a major Hollywood movie coming out this year.
The Korean pop star Rain will star in "Ninja Assassin" from
Warner Bros. Of course, moviegoers
may also recall that Rain also appeared in "Speed Racer," which was
another Japanese animated series that had its main characters suddenly turn
white during the casting for the live-action movie version.
Interestingly enough, a large percentage of major Hollywood
studios like Sony are owned by Asian corporations.
(Hmmm... it makes one wonder if all of this could be some kind of
"strategic decision to appeal to western audiences" handed down from
some anonymous board of directors sitting in a high-rise office building
somewhere? And when you take into
consideration the "branding" of movie franchises and crossover
marketing of movie tie-in products to consumers, which results in hundreds of
millions of dollars in sales, one could logically assume a trickle down effect
is happening with the way movies are being cast in order to maximize revenues
from their "product.")
Ed Moy is an award-winning Asian American writer, actor,
producer. He has written for Asian Week News, Asiance Magazine and 13 Minutes
Magazine. He's a member of the Coalition for Asian Pacifics in Entertainment.
"Desperate Housewives": episode "Now You Know" originally aired September 30, 2007.
Screenwriter: Marc Cherry
Director: Larry Shaw
10/4/07 AFP: 'Desperate' apology over
Philippines
slur,
Manila
(AFP) - Makers of hit US television series "Desperate Housewives"
have apologised for a slur against Filipino medical workers that caused an
uproar in the Southeast Asian country.
The apology was sent to Philippine broadcaster ABS-CBN's
bureau in the
United States
and aired in the
Philippines
on Thursday following protests by the
Manila
government.
"The producers of 'Desperate Housewives' and ABC Studios
offer our sincere apologies for any offense caused by the brief reference in the
season premiere,"
cable news channel ANC quoted the statement as saying.
"There was no intent to disparage the integrity of any
aspect of the medical community in the
Philippines
," it said.
The episode showed actress Teri Hatcher, who plays Susan
Mayer, asking during a medical consultation to check "those diplomas
because I want to make sure that they're not from some med school in the
Philippines
."
The apology was made a day after chief aide to Philippine
President Gloria Arroyo said the line of dialogue appeared to be a "racial
slur."
Philippine Senators said the apology was not enough, and
urged their Foreign Affairs Department to lodge a formal protest with the
US
government.
"I am mortally offended by the statement because it
betrayed the racial prejudice and denigrates the excellent performance of
world-class Filipino doctors in the
US
," said Senator Miriam Santiago, whose sister is a doctor working in
Los Angeles
.
15% of U.S. physicians and surgeons are Asian American.
http://www.ameredia.com/demographics/asian_facts.html
But according to Bigots for the Left, Asian American men do not exist.
Only one TV show in 50+ years has cast Asian
American men as doctors: “House, M.D.”: Kai Penn as Dr. Lawrence Kutner;
Kenneth
Choi as obstetrician
in first season, episode “Maternity” which aired December 7, 2004.
General
Hospital (ABC)
1963 - present
"E.R." (1994 - present) (info
current as of Jan. 2006)
In Hollywood, blacks are doctors and Asian American men are nurses (character
Yosh Takata played by Gedde Watanabe).
Penny Adams, Neal Baer, Tommy Burns, Yahlin Chang,
Christopher Chulack, Samantha Howard Corbin, Michael Crichton, Carol Flint, R.
Scott Gemmill, Lance Gentile, Walon Green, Patrick Harbinson, Julie Hbert,
Michael Hissrich, Dee Johnson, Jonathan Kaplan, Mimi Leder, Paul Manning, Bruce
Miller, David Mills, Chris Misiano, Robert Nathan,
Jack Orman, Tom Park, Joe Sachs, Mike Salamunovich, Teresa Salamunovich, Janine
Sherman, Wendy Spence, Steven Spielberg, Meredith Stiehm, Richard Thorpe, Vicki
Voltarel, John Wells, Virgil Williams,
Lydia
Woodward, David Zabel, Lisa Zwerling
Directors
39 episodes: Jonathan Kaplan
34 episodes: Christopher Chulack
25 episodes: Richard Thorpe
11 episodes: Felix Enriquez Alcala
10 episodes: Mimi Leder, Chris Misiano
9 episodes: Lesli Linka Glatter
8 episodes: Laura Innes
6 episodes: Charkes Haid, John Wells
5 episodes: Rod Holcomb, Paul McCrane, David Nutter
4 episodes: Anthony Edwards, Julie Hebert, Nelson McCormick
3 episodes: Paris Barclay, Alan J. Levi, Jack Orman, Thomas Schlamme, Babu Subramaniam
2 episodes: Arthur Albert, Stephen Cragg, Vondie Curtis-Hall,
Steve De Jarnatt, Donna Deitch, Ernest R. Dickerson, Lance Gentile, Fred Gerber,
Marita Grabiak, James Hayman, Elodie Keene, Ken Kwapis, Darnell Martin, Tom Moore, Gloria Muzio, Peggy Rajski,
Jacque E. Toberen
1 episode: Anita W. Addison, Sarah Pia Anderson, Guy Norman Bee, David
Chameidies, Fred Einesman, Brett Fallis, Vern Gillum, Davis Guggenheim, Kevin
Hooks, Michael Katleman, Barnet Kellman, Eric Laneuville, Perry Lang, Peter
Markle, Tawnia McKiernan, Dean Parisot, Whitney Ransick, Daniel Sackheim, Quentin Tarantino, Mark Tinker, Jesus Trevino, Jessica Yu
Writers:
20+ episodes: John Wells, Jack Orman, Lydia Woodward, R. Scott Gemmill
10+ episodes: David Zabel, Joe Sachs, Dee Johnson, Neal Baer, Carol Flint, Paul
Manning
5+ episodes: Samantha Howard Corbin, Lisa Zwerling, Lance Gentile, Meredith
Stiehm, Walon Green
1+ episodes: David Mills, Yahlin Chang, Julie Hbert, Bruce Miller, Robert
Nathan, Linda Gase, Elizabeth Hunter, Jason Cahill, Patrick Harbinson, Tom
Garrigus, Michael Crichton, Tracey Stern, Jacy Young
1 episode: Barbara Hall, Anne Kenney, Sandy
Kroopf, Christopher Mack, Mark Morocco, Doug Palau, Janine Sherman, Virgil
Williams
1 story: Belinda Casas-Wells, Moreen Littrell
Medical
Center (CBS) 1969 -1976
Marcus Welby, M.D.
(ABC) 1969 - 1976
"Scrubs" (NBC) 2001 - present
?? Had two episodes with Asian American men as physicians and one had a
speaking part! Did have an episode in which Asian American man was mean to
his wife
"Grey's Anatomy" (set in
Seattle) (ABC) 2005 - present
Creator, Executive Producer, writer: Shonda Rhimes
Executive producers: Betsy Beers, Mark Gordon, Peter Horton, Jim Parriott
Directors: Peter Horton, John David Coles, Adam Davidson, Mark Tinker, Wendy
Stanzler
Writers: Zoanne Clack, M.D.,Ann Hamilton, Kip Koenig, Stacy McKee, James D.
Parriott, Mimi Schmir, Gabrielle G. Stanton, Krista Vernoff, Harry Werksman,
Mark Wilding
Strong
Medicine (Lifetime TV) 2000 -
present
Nip/Tuck (F/X)
2003 - present
7/4/06 In These Times: Perpetuating the
Yellow Peril,
by Lakshmi Chaudhry
Mako, an actor who has appeared in over 90 feature films,
talks about stereotypic portrayals he has had to struggle against.
At first glance, Jeff Adachi's Slanted Screen is an earnest
documentary that covers familiar ground. The shameful depiction of
minoritiesin this case, Asian-American menin television and film is hardly
news. What makes the movie special, however, is that it offers a rare view of
Hollywood
from the inside. Apart from the occasional talking head, the interviewees are
actors, producers, directors and screenwriters.
Part of the movie's interest lies in their horror stories,
which are likely to make even the most jaded viewer cringe. Producer Terence
Changwhose big-budget credits include Mission Impossible II, Face-Off and
Broken Arrow
describes being told to change the race of the white villain in the script
for the Chow Yun Fat vehicle, The Replacement Killers , and make him a Chinese
druglord instead. The logic: "If the hero is Asian then the bad guys have
to be Asian as well." The racism is open and unapologetic.
As gruesome as such anecdotes may be, Slanted Screen is most
compelling when its subjects explore the conflict between who they are and what they do. It
may be hard to watch a repulsive Long Duk Dong slobbering over the girl in
Sixteen Candles, but it's harder still to be the guy who plays him: Gedde
Watanabe, a Japanese- American actor born and raised in Utah, who put on a fake
accent to utter immortal lines, such as "No more yankie my wankie. The
Donger need food."
In the seven-minute short film The Screen Testwhich was
screened along with Slanted Screen in
San Francisco
actress Judy Lee sums up every Asian actor's moral dilemma: "Our
paychecks come from stereotypes." When there are practically no roles for
Asians, a script that calls for an "opium den mistress" is a cause for
celebration.
The art of survival lies in enduring what you must, and
quietly changing what you can within
Hollywood's stifling parameters. What may look like just another stereotype from the
outside may in fact be a serious attempt to challenge industry norms. A good
example is what has become Hollywood
's favorite Asian character: the martial arts warrior. Bruce Lee may seem to be
just another uni-dimensional macho hero, but his rise marked an epochal shift
for Asian Americans, both as actors and as men. After decades of being demonized
as sly yet effeminate "yellow peril" in the post-World War II era, Lee
represented a positive, vigorous version of masculinity. And it's this
consolation that actors like
Cary
-Hiroyuki Tagawa cling to when they play similar roles in movies like Mortal
Kombat, even when they're negative. "If the choice is between playing wimpy
business men and the bad guy," Tagawa tells Adachi, "I'd rather play
the bad guy. I want kids to know that Asian men have balls."
When Hollywood
allows Asian leading men to be macho, it rarely gives them the privilege of
being "American." "Asian Americans tend to be looked at as
perpetual aliens," says author and poet David Mura. "In other words,
an Asian-American male can't be seen as representative of all Americans in the
way Tom Cruise or Tom Hanks or even Denzel Washington can."
According to
University
of
Delaware English
professor Peter X. Feng, the benefit of safely foreign heroes such as Jet Li or
Chow Yun Fat is that "they come to these shores to solve a problem and then
they leave. So there is never any question of integrating them into the American
body politic." In this sense, Mura argues, Asian- American men are worse
off than women, who "are more easily assimilated by the white psyche in
part because they are seen as sexually available to white men." Hence
Lucy Liu can be one of Charlie's Angels, but no one would cast, say, Jason Scott
Lee in a remake of Starsky and Hutchthough
Hollywood
execs were only too happy to cast him as an Indian in The Jungle Book .
While there have been exceptions to this depressing normDustin Nguyen as Officer Harry Ioki in "21 Jump Street" or more recently, Harold and
Kumar Go to
White Castlethe predicament facing Asian male actors today is grim compared to Hollywood's silent era, when Sessue Hayakawa rivaled Douglas Fairbanks,
Charlie Chaplin and John Barrymore in popularity as a leading man. But despite his Rudolf Valentino-esque persona, even Hayakawa almost never got the girl
not unless she was played by his own Japanese wife, Aoki. His present-day counterparts are no better off. Chow Yun Fat never gets to kiss Mira Sorvino in
Replacement Killers, while the creators of Romeo Must Die edited out the sole
kiss between Aaliyah and Jet Li. "To say it doesn't affect us is
bullshit," declares Tagawa, the anguish bubbling to the surface as he exclaims, "We're not
eunuchs!"
The stark contrast between the sexual images of Asian men and
women on-screen follows the dictates of age-old colonialist logic, where the sexual
appropriation of women is accompanied by the emasculation of the men. That the documentary never includes a discussion of women, or their perspective, is a
glaring omission. The very action hero roles that seem to affirm Asian
masculinity can be deeply problematic from a feminist perspective. Is a Schwarzenegger-like
machismo really the kind of Asian male identity that we want to promote?
The sexual politics are even more complicated. Take, for example,
the comments of Gene Cajayon, who directed one of the first Filipino-American movies, The Debut (2000). Cajayon says it was important for him to make his
lead character "someone who is attractive to white girls" so as to
establish his credentials as a bona fide "cool kid." But how subversive is this
character if his
masculinity requires a white seal of sexual approval and treats white women as mere markers of his prowess?
A more compassionate interpretation of this desire is to see it
instead as a hunger to be seen as sexual, period. That it entails white affirmation is merely
a sad acknowledgement of the requirements of the broader culture we live in.
"It seems to me unfair to question the desire of Asian-American men to feel
sexually attractive," says Mura. "If an African-American man were to
say, for
instance, that he wanted to be appreciated for his intelligence and not just stereotyped for sexual or athletic prowess, would we say he was succumbing to
a trap which defined real male worth by intelligence?"
Mura argues that Asian men "desire a complete picture of
ourselves and to be valued as complete individuals. We desire respect in those areas where we
feel we are disrespected. We don't get to pick and choose where those areas are." But we are more likely to see a more "complete" picture of
Asian men if we portray them as they are rather than as ethnic versions of
Hollywood
gender-laden fantasies of manhood that haven't served white men well. In fact, those kind of movies will be just as valuable for the rest of us, male or
female, Asian or otherwise.
Lakshmi Chaudhry has been a reporter and an editor for
independent publications for more than six years, and is a senior editor at In These Times,
where she covers the cross-section of culture and politics.
6/5/07 Miami Herald (Los Angeles Times
Service): White male writers dominate
Hollywood
film, television jobs: The earnings gap between minorities and white males
working in film and television has steadily widened, according to a Writers
Guild study,
by Richard Verrier
Hollywood -- Despite some advances by women and minority
writers, white male scribes disproportionately dominate film and TV jobs in
Hollywood
, according to a study released by the Writers Guild of America, West.
More than 30 percent of the
U.S.
population is nonwhite, the study noted, yet minority writers accounted for
less than 10 percent of employed television writers between 1999 and 2005. In
film, the share of minority writers remained at 6 percent, unchanged since 1999,
according to the sixth in a series of reports by the guild examining employment
and earnings of its members.
''Little progress has been made,'' said the report's author,
University
of
California
,
Los Angeles
sociology Professor Darnell Hunt.
What's more, he said, next year's numbers will likely be
worse due to the recent merger of the UPN and WB networks into the new CW, which
resulted in the canceling of several minority-themed shows
Union officials released the latest findings hoping to
influence hiring for the upcoming television season.
''The disturbing problem which underlies the need for this
report is matched only by the disturbing lack of change that has been the
industry's response,'' Guild leader Patric Verrone said.
The earnings gap between minorities and white males working
in film and television has steadily widened, with minority writers earning
$83,334 in 2005, compared to $118,357 for white males.
Women television writers, however, earned virtually the same
as men in 2005, after an earnings gap of $10,000 in 2004. Nonetheless, the
median income for female film writers was $40,000 less for males.
While older writers earned the most, they are significantly
underrepresented on show staffs, the report states.
6/1/07 Washington Post: "At Med Schools, a New Degree of Diversity: Classes
Reflect A Foreign Flavor,"
by David Brown
The six members of Medical Team 4 have a lot in common. Each
wears a white coat, has a stethoscope for a necklace and has stayed up late this
week. They can all start an IV and work up a solitary lung nodule.
They share something less obvious, too. With one exception,
none has a grandparent born in the United States.
Med 4 at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Northwest
Washington is the new face of American medicine. Its members happen to come from
Georgetown and George Washington universities, but the team is indistinguishable
from similar groups of young doctors and doctors-to-be at many of the country's
125 medical schools.
In the past 15 years, U.S. medicine has seen a huge influx of
first- and second-generation immigrants. It follows and augments a different
demographic trend that began 30 years ago with the acceptance of increasing
numbers of women into medical schools. As a result of that earlier revolutionary
change, half of new practitioners today are women.
The Norman Rockwell-Marcus Welby image of the American doctor
-- an avuncular white man, often in a bow tie -- is rapidly disappearing.
From 1980 to 2004, the fraction of medical school graduates
describing themselves as white fell from 85 percent to 64 percent. Over that
same period, the percentage of Asians increased from 3 percent to 20 percent,
with Indians and Chinese the two biggest ethnic groups.
Counted in the "white" category, moreover, are a
moderate number of ethnic Persians whose families fled the 1979 Iranian
revolution, and a smaller number of more recent arrivals from Eastern Europe and
the former Soviet Union. In the "black" category is an unknown number
of graduates whose families recently arrived from Africa, predominantly
Nigerians and Ghanaians.
"We are seeing more and more kids of foreign-born
parents, especially in the last eight to 10 years. I don't think there is any
doubt about it," said Milford M. Foxwell, a physician and dean of
admissions at the University of Maryland School of Medicine. In his 18 years on
the job, he has reviewed about 75,000 applications.
Many forces are sketching this changing portrait of the
American medical student. They include a general increase in immigration, a
large influx of foreigners trained in scientific and technical professions, and
a culture of educational achievement in communities of newly arrived immigrants
that prepares their children for the competition and rigors of medical school.
How -- or whether -- this trend will change the practice of
medicine in this country is uncertain.
There is a small amount of evidence that a diverse student
body may be more attuned to disparities in medical care than a homogeneous one.
A study published in 2004 found that black, Hispanic and Asian medical students
(in descending order) are more likely than white ones to think that U.S.
medicine often "treats people unfairly" based on race, ethnicity,
insurance status, income or ability to speak English.
In general, though, few are eager to touch on the
implications of the new ethnic mix in medical schools. Officials at institutions
as different as the University of Vermont and Howard University declined
multiple requests to discuss, even anecdotally, the evolution of their student
makeup.
In the case of Med 4, its roots stretch to India (two
students), Bangladesh (one), Austria (one) and Russia (one). The sole team
member without a family narrative of recent arrival is African American.
The door to the team's office at the VA hospital humorously
telegraphs an awareness that the people inside the windowless warren of
cubicles, computers, backpacks and water bottles are not quite a random sample
of America. Someone has taped on it a page from the supermarket tabloid Weekly
World News.
"Your doctor could be an alien! They're working
undercover!" shouts the headline. Under it is a photo of four
masked-and-gowned physicians -- one with dark space-creature eyes -- gathered
around a supine patient.
Team 4's international coloration includes even its senior
physician, Divya Shroff, an assistant professor of medicine at GW.
Her father immigrated from India to study chemical
engineering in graduate school, returned to India to marry, then came back to
the United States with his bride. Shroff and her younger brother and sister grew
up in the Chicago suburbs but spent three years in New Delhi in the 1980s. Her
brother is also a physician, her sister an investment banker.
"We were never forced into medicine," she said
recently in her office at the VA hospital. "But in the Indian community in
Chicago, everyone was a professional. Everyone was a doctor or an
engineer."
She went from high school into a program at the University of
Missouri where students got both a bachelor's degree and a medical degree in six
years. Of the 10 people in her group, "maybe one was Caucasian," she
recalled. The majority were Indians.
The culture of high expectation holds true for another South
Asian on the team, resident Moneera Haque, who grew up in Bethesda with parents
who immigrated from Bangladesh.
Haque, 30, has a doctorate in social work along with her
medical degree. She recently presented a paper on "racial differences in
utilization of cardiac rehabilitation" at a scientific meeting in New
Orleans and another paper at a conference in Amsterdam. Her brother is a
neurosurgeon.
In her household, the notion that education came first
"was simply the way things were," Haque said while sipping a drink in
a break room. "For me, that didn't seem like pressure." But she
admitted she wasn't studying just for herself: "We have a sense of
obligation to our parents to help them fulfill their dreams as well."
Alexandra Langer, a third-year medical student at GW, traced
a distinctly different path.
Langer, 30, grew up in Yekaterinburg, in central Russia. Her
father managed a pension fund, and her mother was a police officer. As a high
school student, she aspired to become a doctor, but her parents talked her out
of it.
"In Russia, doctors are much lower status than
here," she said. "And they are very low-paid."
So at 18 she left home and moved to Prague, where she studied
Czech, English and international relations, but she never really gave up her
original idea. She married an American, moved to the United States, graduated
from college in North Carolina and got into medical school.
"It seems like a very, very long time," she said.
"But it's worth it."
Although the Association of American Medical Colleges asks
all medical school applicants and matriculants to describe their race and
ethnicity in general terms, there is little published information about national
background and none about family history. Anecdotes, however, suggest that
immigrants' children are more likely to attend schools on both coasts.
S. Balasubramaniam, a surgeon at Charles R. Drew University
of Medicine and Science in Los Angeles who emigrated from India in 1971,
recently queried 50 medical schools and calculated that 12 percent of the class
that entered in 2006 is of Indian heritage. The highest percentages are in
California, Texas, New York, New Jersey and New England.
Na Shen, 25, a second-year medical student at Maryland who
was born in Shanghai, calculated that 12 percent of her school's students are
from China, Taiwan, Korea and Japan, and 1 percent from Southeast Asia. When
South Asians are included, the Asian portion of the school rises to 21 percent.
In contrast, University of Kansas medical school students
since 1996 have consistently run about 10 percent "either born overseas or
of parents who were born overseas," said Glendon Cox, the vice dean.
The most recent arrivals -- Africans -- are the hardest to
quantify.
Morehouse School of Medicine, in Atlanta, has 12 students
born in Africa out of about 210 in the M.D. program. Meharry Medical College,
another historically black institution, in the past eight years has had an
average of two foreigners per year in its incoming classes of about 60. It has
no data, however, on students with recent ties to Africa who are U.S. citizens
or permanent residents. Howard, the third historically black medical school, did
not provide information when asked.
A half-dozen people at the Student National Medical
Association -- the main U.S. organization of black medical students -- did not
respond to inquiries.
Lauree Thomas, an African American physician who is associate
dean for admissions at the University of Texas Medical Branch in Galveston,
estimated that "20 to 30 percent of the black applicant pool" at her
school is students who were born in Nigeria, or of Nigerian parents. Foxwell,
the Maryland dean, estimates that close to half the black students there have
recent ties to Africa.
This is a touchy subject in the black medical community.
Albert Morris Jr., a diagnostic radiologist in Memphis who is
president of the predominantly black National Medical Association, said he
recently talked to black students at Pennsylvania State University's medical
school in Hershey. Afterward, several took him aside and quietly complained
about the rising number of Africans.
"It was a big topic -- that people were coming in and
getting slots that they thought should be going to African Americans," he
recalled.
Blacks constitute about 13 percent of the U.S. population,
but only 4 percent of U.S. doctors. There has been much effort in the last two
decades to remedy this imbalance. Morris, a graduate of Howard, said he
understands the students' sensitivities.
"We are happy to see doctors who are ready to treat
minority populations, no matter their nationality," said Morris, 56.
"But we want to make sure that those of us who have helped open the doors
[to medical school for blacks] get to share in the bounty."